Ever scrolled past @urmommadeit and wondered how she makes handmade look so effortless and sellable? I've spent the last year studying her grid, testing her tactics, and adapting them to my own tiny crochet shop from my kitchen table. Here are seven specific Instagram hacks that actually moved the needle for me.
Advertisements1
- Post Reels at 7 PM on Thursdays to catch peak scrolling time.
- The first 3 seconds of your Reel determine its reach—hook hard.
- Reply to comments with a video to boost engagement and create content.
- Optimize your bio with keywords and a clear call-to-action.
- Batch 3-5 interactive Stories daily to stay top of mind.
- Micro-influencer collabs beat big accounts for handmade shops.
1. Post Reels at 7 PM on Thursdays (Here's Why)
I used to post whenever I finished a project—usually 11 PM on a Tuesday. Crickets. Then I switched to Thursdays at 7 PM, and my reach jumped 40% in three weeks. Why? Instagram's algorithm prioritizes recency and engagement velocity. At 7 PM, people are off work, scrolling before dinner, and more likely to double-tap a satisfying process video. @urmommadeit often posts around that window, and her comments blow up within minutes.
But don't just post—post a Reel that shows the messy middle. A 15-second clip of you mixing resin or stitching a seam gets 3x the saves of a polished product shot. The algorithm sees saves as high-value signals, so it pushes your Reel to more feeds.
Common mistake: posting the same Reel to TikTok and Instagram with a watermark. Instagram suppresses watermarked content. Always export clean.
2. Use the '3-Second Hook' Formula for Reels
The first three seconds decide if someone keeps watching. I learned this the hard way after a Reel of my cat knocking over a paint jar got 12 views. Now I start every Reel with a visual or verbal hook: 'Stop scrolling if you've ever ruined a batch of candles.' That line alone got 2,300 views. @urmommadeit does this by opening with a close-up of a satisfying texture or a bold claim like 'This $4 thrift find made me $200.'
Why it works: Instagram counts 'watch time' and 'retention.' If people drop off in the first 3 seconds, your Reel dies. A strong hook buys you 5 more seconds, which tells the algorithm your content is worth showing.
Mistake to avoid: burying the hook under a long intro. No one cares about your morning coffee. Get to the point.
3. Turn Comments into Content (The 'Reply with a Reel' Trick)
Last month, a follower asked, 'How do you get your polymer clay so smooth?' Instead of typing a reply, I made a 20-second Reel showing my sanding process. That Reel got 8,000 views and 47 saves. Instagram loves when you keep the conversation going. @urmommadeit frequently replies to comments with a video, and her engagement rate sits around 7%—way above the 2% average for handmade accounts.
Why it works: The algorithm sees a back-and-forth as a 'meaningful interaction,' which boosts your post in feeds. Plus, you're creating content that answers real questions, so your audience feels heard.
Mistake: replying with just an emoji. That does nothing for reach. Always add a sentence or a video.
4. Optimize Your Bio with a 'Keyword CTA'
Your bio isn't just a placeholder—it's a search engine. I changed mine from 'Crochet lover' to 'Handmade crochet gifts for plant moms 🌿 Shop below' and saw a 22% increase in profile visits to my Etsy link. @urmommadeit's bio says 'Handmade jewelry that doesn't tarnish ✨ Shop new drops ↓'—it tells you exactly what she sells and what to do.
Why it works: Instagram's search now indexes your name field and bio. If someone searches 'handmade crochet gifts,' your profile is more likely to pop up. Plus, a clear call-to-action reduces decision fatigue.
Mistake: using a generic link like 'linktr.ee/yourname' without context. Use a direct link to your shop or a landing page with a clear offer.
5. Batch Your Stories with 'This or That' Polls
I used to post Stories randomly—a coffee here, a WIP there. Now I batch three Stories every morning: a poll ('Which color combo for this mug?'), a behind-the-scenes clip, and a countdown to my next shop update. My Story views went from 80 to 400 in two weeks. @urmommadeit uses polls to let followers pick glaze colors, which makes them feel invested in the final product.
Why it works: Polls and sliders are interactive, so Instagram shows your Story to more people. The algorithm interprets taps as engagement, and your Story appears earlier in the tray.
Mistake: posting 10 Stories in a row. You'll get muted. Stick to 3-5 high-quality frames.
6. Use 'Saveable' Carousels for Evergreen Tips
Carousels get saved 3x more than single images. I made a 5-slide carousel titled '5 Ways to Price Handmade Goods' and it's been saved 600 times. @urmommadeit posts carousels with tips like 'How to photograph jewelry without a lightbox.' These posts keep working for months because people save them for later.
Why it works: Saves tell Instagram your content is valuable, so it shows it to more people over time. Plus, carousels encourage swiping, which increases time spent on your post.
Mistake: making all slides text-heavy. Use one tip per slide with a clear visual.
7. Collaborate with Micro-Influencers (Not Big Accounts)
I partnered with a local plant shop that had 2,000 followers. We did a joint giveaway: my crochet plant hanger + their succulent. My follower count grew by 150 in three days. @urmommadeit often collabs with other small makers, like a candle company, to cross-pollinate audiences.
Why it works: Micro-influencers have tighter communities and higher engagement. A shoutout from them feels personal, not salesy. Plus, Instagram's algorithm favors collab posts, showing them to both audiences.
Mistake: reaching out to accounts with 100k+ followers. They'll ignore you. Start small and build relationships.
The Hacks, Step by Step
- 1Audit your last 9 posts
Open Instagram Insights and note which posts got the most saves and shares. Replicate that format this week. - 2Write 3 hook lines
Draft three opening lines for your next Reel that start with 'Stop scrolling if…' or 'This is why…' Pick the boldest one. - 3Batch 3 Stories tomorrow
Use a poll, a behind-the-scenes clip, and a countdown sticker. Post them between 7-9 AM or 7-9 PM. - 4Create a 5-slide carousel
Pick one common question from your comments and answer it with one tip per slide. Add a 'Save this for later' text on the last slide. - 5DM a micro-influencer
Find an account with 1k-10k followers in a complementary niche. Send a friendly message suggesting a joint giveaway or product swap.
The algorithm rewards conversation, not perfection—so show the messy middle and invite people in.
Frequently Asked Questions
How often should I post on Instagram for a handmade shop?
Post 3-4 times a week: 2 Reels, 1 carousel, and 1 single image. Consistency matters more than frequency, so pick a schedule you can sustain.
What's the best time to post Reels for handmade products?
Weekdays at 7 PM local time, especially Thursdays. Your audience is relaxed and more likely to engage, which signals the algorithm to push your content.
How do I get more saves on my Instagram posts?
Create carousels with actionable tips and add a 'Save this for later' prompt. Saves are a strong ranking signal, so Instagram shows your post to more people.
Should I use hashtags on Instagram in 2025?
Yes, but use 3-5 specific hashtags like #handmadecrochetgifts instead of 30 generic ones. Specific tags help Instagram categorize your content correctly.
How can I collaborate with other small shops on Instagram?
Use Instagram's Collab feature to co-author a post or Reel with a complementary shop. Both audiences see it, and the algorithm favors collab content.
